In the Court of Public Opinion

I am going home to cover a big story, just like old times. When 4,000 United Mine Workers and community supporters rally Tuesday, June 4, at the Henderson County (Ky.) Courthouse, I’ll be there to write about it, to blog live in my hometown, where I began my career as a newspaper reporter.

This is a story that Henderson should know well, the fight by coal miners to earn a decent living, to survive in a dangerous job. Coal was King in Henderson for many years, along with corn, soybean and tobacco, now overtaken by marijuana, as markets change, including energy. Coal has fallen on hard times, but not nearly so much as the miners who spent decades underground mining the coal. Many struggle for breath, many live out their lives in pain.


A retiree rallies in St. Louis. The rigors of coal mining have taken their toll on miners, but they’re fighting back through the United Mine Workers of America.

These are men and women dependent on health care benefits that St. Louis-based Peabody Energy and Arch Coal promised to deliver but dodged artfully through a corporate swindle – I don’t know how else to describe it. They have offloaded their retirement obligations to these miners onto a little company that may have been “created to fail.” Patriot Coal filed for bankruptcy last year and is getting a gentle hand from U.S. bankruptcy court, even as Peabody and Arch wash their hands, like Pontius Pilate.

And here’s the lead: Patriot Coal on Wednesday, May 28, was awarded a bankruptcy court ruling that essentially gave the company the green light to gut the contracts of 1,700 active Mine Workers and strip life-saving health care benefits from 23,000 retirees and their family members. The Mine Workers immediately announced they would appeal the ruling, and continue their fight in other courts, in Congress and in the court of public opinion.

Now the story is coming to Henderson, and I believe it is a place where miners can get a fair hearing – at least in the court of public opinion. Patriot operates the Highland mine in adjoining Union County, and until last summer operated the Freedom mine in Henderson. Patriot shut down Freedom and others in West Virginia, and many are operating well below capacity. It’s a bittersweet reminder for citizens of Henderson that coal has always held both promise and peril.

Every coalfield family has been affected by the rigors of coal mining.  They’ve all lost friends and relatives to pneumoconiosis (black lung) and other respiratory diseases, or to the dangerous life underground. Coal is part of the DNA of these communities, and UMWA health care is a lifeline to the next day. Sadly, every American is affected by the erosion of health benefits, and by courts that increasingly favor the rights of corporations over the rights of individuals.

That is where we are today, facing a judicial system that somehow gives corporations the rights of people, while diminishing the rights of real people. “As often happens under American bankruptcy law, the short-term interests of the company are valued more than the dedication and sacrifice of the workers, who actually produce the profits that make a company successful,” said Cecil Roberts, president of the United Mine Workers of America (UMWA).

Roberts has vowed to continue the fight in every forum, including in federal court in Charleston, where the UMWA has sued Peabody and Arch for violations of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), alleging the companies conspired to deny benefits to their longtime employees and their families.

“Peabody and Arch can decide to live up to their obligations and end this problem tomorrow,” Robert said. “But if they don’t, we will continue our litigation against them and are optimistic about our chances.”

The rally in Henderson next week continues an aggressive campaign by the Mine Workers to make the miners’ case for justice in the communities where they live, where they raised their kids and contributed to local economies often driven by coal. As a young reporter, I waded through records at the Henderson County Courthouse, tracking the trade in mineral rights, to Peabody, Reynolds and other industry heavyweights of the day.


The Henderson County (Ky.) Courthouse, where 4,000 Mine Worker and their supporters will rally next Tuesday.

Now it’s come to this: Giant coal companies that extracted the mineral wealth of communities now discard the workers who made their fortunes on a gob pile, like they were merely the waste of the operation – a sad reflection on corporate America. But we also are witnessing the courage and the determination of the miners and their union.

While the UMWA train stops in Henderson as it searches for justice, inevitably it is on its way to Washington, D.C., where the voices of miners already are being heard.

U.S. Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.), denouncing the bankruptcy court ruling as a “travesty,” declared, “It is wrong that Peabody can set up a company such as Patriot, fill that company with its liabilities and then spin that company off for the sole purpose of avoiding its contractual and moral obligations to its workers. I don’t think bankruptcy laws were ever designed to shield corporations from their promises and responsibilities. I will continue to fight for fairness in the bankruptcy system.”

This is a fight that affects us all. Stay tuned. You will be able to follow the action in Henderson via the live blog, or watch it via livestream video here, beginning at 10 a.m. CT Tuesday, June 4.

5 thoughts on “In the Court of Public Opinion

  1. Yes, don’t forget to report that the Judge ruled that the Company CEO gets $6.9 million in bonuses. For what? Rewarding the company for driving it into bankruptcy? And cut the throats of the men and their families, who desperately need this healthcare? Treat them like they are trash, thrown to the side, to be forgotten about? Does this seem fair? I should think not! This is so sickening it makes me want to puke! Coal corporations have always wanted to stiff the hard-working coal miner. Mine wars all down thru the years past, killing people, men, women and children! Instead of the corporations hiring guns to kill them, they hire three-piece pin-stripe lawyers to do their killing legally by paper! No, people shouldn’t take this, we demand justice. I heard and read that there were new coal mines opening up in Kentucky — either 5 or 7. Does it seem like coal is hurting all that badly like they would want us to think? Or is this another scheme of theirs to go along with this scheme! People know what Peabody, Arch and Patriot have done, they schemed up a company calling it Patriot (which doesn’t deserve to be called patriot — if anything, there are a lot of veterans in this fight who are the REAL Patriots) to put these people in so that way they could write them off once and for all! Religious leaders and everyone should see what this is about. It’s an attack on human rights, doing these people wrongly, so many who are too sick to defend for themselves, and I for one will be there to carry their voice with me!

  2. Some people kill with the gun, others like that sorry piece called a judge kill with a pen…take away her pension and health care paid by us taxpayers. Put her out on the street with the other poor souls. And another complaint: How come the minorities, lower-middle and middle class have to fight and die for this country while the ultra rich throw parties and spend their monies trying to put the working class down…bastards all!

  3. I will be there. I am a 63-year-old miner who is still working at patriot coal highland mine.
    I started with Peabody in 1973, same employee number still.

  4. I agree with Charles. Take away the medical benefits of the judge that ruled against us. Take away the same from her family and friends. Does she even know what she has done? She must be very selfish to do this. I think we will come out on top, and she will have to answer for what she has done. Maybe not in this lifetime, but to a much higher power. What will her answer be when asked..”Did you do all you could for the people? Did you treat them fairly?”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s